01“The Fathers use the language of flesh and blood, but the language of a mystery — the same way Jesus speaks in John 6.”
This is the strongest objection and it deserves a real answer. Augustine does say that the words are to be understood spiritually, and he can speak of the sacrament as a figure. But spiritual and figurative are not the same as unreal: in the same century Chrysostom and Ambrose are saying that the bread is no longer bread, and Cyril is arguing from Christ's word. The figurative reading also has to explain why Ignatius, in 107, treats denial of the Eucharistic flesh as the same error as denial of the Incarnation, and why the Church has never once in nineteen centuries read the passages as memorial only. The honest position is this: the Fathers' mode of explanation shifted, their conviction did not. What developed was the how — the word transubstantiation is a twelfth-century instrument, and Thomas, its greatest exponent, insists it names a change beyond anything in created nature.
02“The Mass repeats Calvary, and Hebrews 10 forbids any further sacrifice.”
Half of that is conceded outright: the Church has defined that the Mass adds nothing to the Cross, that the sacrifice is one, once for all, and that what is offered here is the same offering made present, not repeated. Hebrews is quoted in the Roman Canon. But note how early the sacrificial language is. The Didache, before 100, speaks of gathering to “offer the pure sacrifice” in fulfilment of Malachi 1:11; Justin says the same; Irenaeus says it twice. If sacrifice belongs to the second century's plain meaning, the question is not whether the Church offers something, but what it is doing when it does — and the whole Catholic answer is anamnesis: a memorial that makes present, in the same way that Israel was told to keep the Passover “as a memorial” and to say “this is what the Lord did for me” (Exodus 13:8).
03“The medieval Mass turned the people into spectators — and that corruption was real.”
It was, and this is the one place where the Reformers were substantially right. Between the thirteenth and twentieth centuries: communion under one kind for the laity, Latin alone, the Prayer of the Faithful lost, the offertory processions gone, side altars with private Masses, the people reciting the rosary while a priest did the essential business at the far end. The Second Vatican Council said so in its own words, and made restoration the first item of business — vernacular, full participation, restored prayers of the faithful, communion under both kinds, a three-year lectionary, the homily. The Protestant objection was answered by the Church admitting the complaint and beginning to repair the damage.
04“You cannot show that today's Roman rite is what the apostles did.”
You cannot, and the Church has never claimed the manuscript was dictated in the upper room. What is first-century is the shape: assembly, readings and exposition, prayers for all, the peace, bread and wine, thanksgiving, the words of Christ, communion, collection for the poor, dismissal. That is Justin's Sunday in 155 and it is still the fourfold structure of the Mass. What is later is visible too: the Kyrie came from the East, the Creed arrived at Rome around 1014, the Canon fixed around 600, the synaxis and the Eucharist were once separate and were joined. The claim is continuity of substance, not identity of form — and a Protestant whose own liturgy keeps collects, readings, creed, sursum corda, sanctus and the Lord's Prayer is making the same claim about the same continuity, from the other side.
05“Marian devotion, the saints, and the cult of relics have crowded Christ out of the liturgy.”
Look at the actual text. The Mass's prayers are addressed to the Father through Christ, its readings are Christ, its Canon's consecration is Christ's own words, its communion is Christ, and the name of Mary and of the apostles appears once each in the intercessions of the Roman Canon — as those asked to pray, exactly as you would ask a living friend to pray, and as the Creed you may share says in “the communion of saints.” Popular piety has sometimes crowded that out, and where it has, the Church's own liturgical texts are the standard to judge it by, not the devotional excess. A service judged against the Missal, not against a shrine, is difficult to accuse of being Christ-less.
06“A sermon with a table, a hymn and a Bible is already Christ-centred. Why would I need the Mass?”
If you are convinced that the bread and wine are only signs, this objection is decisive, and no amount of archaeology answers it. But if the question is only where the greater centre of gravity lies, consider what is actually being claimed. The Mass is not a service with Christ as its subject; it is prayer addressed to him and to the Father through him, with his words on the priest's lips, his Body on the altar, and his Church sent out at the end. The Reformers themselves did not abandon that centre — Luther kept the elevation and the words as Christ's, Cranmer kept the sursum corda and the sanctus and the dominical words in the 1549 rite. The disagreement was never about whether Christ is the centre. It was about what he puts in your hands.