Metanoia Faith
A simple stone altar with a gold chalice and paten, an open Bible on a lectern and an open hymnal, incense haze in golden window light.
Augsburg · 31 October 1999

The Doctrine That Split Europe Has Been Agreed in Common

On the last day of October 1999, the Catholic Church and the Lutheran World Federation signed a Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification. It does not say the two churches are the same. It says something narrower and more startling: that the condemnations of the sixteenth century no longer apply to what the other church now teaches.

1999

Signed at Augsburg

§41

The condemnations no longer apply

5

Communions now associated

The Agreement Itself

What Catholics and Lutherans Now Say Together

The Declaration is short — forty-four paragraphs. It works by two moves: first it states what both sides confess together (§§15–18), then it takes each old point of dispute in turn and shows that each side's emphasis is compatible with the other's (§§19–39). Where it quotes a shared affirmation, both churches are speaking. The paragraph numbers are given so nothing here has to be taken on trust.

§5, in its own words: the Declaration “does not cover all that either church teaches about justification; it does encompass a consensus on basic truths of the doctrine of justification and shows that the remaining differences in its explication are no longer the occasion for doctrinal condemnations.”

01

Grace alone, and nothing added

“Together we confess: By grace alone, in faith in Christ’s saving work and not because of any merit on our part, we are accepted by God and receive the Holy Spirit, who renews our hearts while equipping and calling us to good works.”

Joint Declaration, §15

Read the sentence twice. It is the sentence Trent was accused of denying, written by Catholics and Lutherans together. Grace is God’s favour, not a wage; and the renewal of the heart is the gift carried inside the same act of acceptance, not a second thing we supply.

02

Not even the will contributes

“We confess together that all persons depend completely on the saving grace of God for their salvation … Justification takes place solely by God’s grace.”

Joint Declaration, §19

This is the fight of 1517, settled by distinguishing rather than dividing. What Catholics call cooperating is itself a gift: “such personal consent as itself an effect of grace, not as an action arising from innate human abilities” (§20). What Lutherans exclude is any contribution: the person “can only receive” justification, which nevertheless does not deny that “believers are fully involved personally in their faith, which is effected by God’s Word” (§21).

Catholic

Consent to grace is the effect of grace, never a merit.

Lutheran

The sinner contributes nothing; faith is God’s creative word in us.

03

Christ alone — and faith as His gift

“Through Christ alone are we justified, when we receive this salvation in faith. Faith is itself God’s gift through the Holy Spirit who works through word and sacrament in the community of believers.”

Joint Declaration, §16

Note where faith comes from: through word and sacrament, in the community of believers. The Declaration does not set the sacrament against faith — it names the sacrament as one of the channels by which the gift of faith arrives. Solus Christus was never a slogan for a private religion.

04

Forgiven and made new — one act, not two

“We confess together that God forgives sin by grace and at the same time frees human beings from sin’s enslaving power and imparts the gift of new life in Christ … These two aspects of God’s gracious action are not to be separated.”

Joint Declaration, §22

The old quarrel was whether justification is a verdict or a transformation. The Declaration says the two emphases were never rivals: the Lutheran insistence on “the righteousness of Christ” through “the declaration of forgiveness” does not deny renewal (§23); the Catholic insistence on “the renewal of the interior person” does not deny that justification “remains independent of human cooperation” (§24).

Lutheran

“The favour of God” — the verdict is free and complete.

Catholic

Forgiving grace “always brings with it a gift of new life.”

05

Faith alone — said in full

“We confess together that sinners are justified by faith in the saving action of God in Christ … Such a faith is active in love and thus the Christian cannot and should not remain without works. But whatever in the justified precedes or follows the free gift of faith is neither the basis of justification nor merits it.”

Joint Declaration, §25

Both halves are essential. Works do not justify; and a faith that produces no love is not the faith of the gospel. The Catholic paragraph says “the Catholic understanding also sees faith as fundamental in justification. For without faith, no justification can take place” (§27) — and adds that justifying grace “never becomes a human possession to which one could appeal over against God.” The caricature ends here.

06

Righteous, and still a sinner

“We confess together that in baptism the Holy Spirit unites one with Christ, justifies, and truly renews the person. But the justified must all through life constantly look to God’s unconditional justifying grace … The justified also must ask God daily for forgiveness as in the Lord’s Prayer.”

Joint Declaration, §28

Luther’s simul iustus et peccator — at once righteous and sinner (§29) — and the Catholic teaching on concupiscence (§30) turn out to describe the same experience from two angles: no condemnation remains, and yet the struggle is lifelong. Catholics do not claim sinlessness for the baptised; Lutherans do not claim that sin still separates the justified.

07

Good works are fruit, and they are obligatory

“We confess together that good works — a Christian life lived in faith, hope and love — follow justification and are its fruits … this consequence of justification is also for them an obligation they must fulfill.”

Joint Declaration, §37

Catholics were accused of selling works; Lutherans of permitting licence. The Declaration rules out both. Catholic “merit” is explained as a promised reward, not a claim: “a reward in heaven is promised to these works” (§38). And Lutherans are said to hold “a preservation of grace and a growth in grace and faith” (§39). Grace remains gift at every stage.

08

Assurance, without presumption

“We confess together that the faithful can rely on the mercy and promises of God … on the strength of Christ’s death and resurrection they can build on the effective promise of God’s grace in Word and Sacrament and so be sure of this grace.”

Joint Declaration, §34

The Reformers’ concern is acknowledged as Catholic concern: “in the midst of temptation, believers should not look to themselves but look solely to Christ and trust only him” (§35). And the Catholic caution is acknowledged as Lutheran caution: “no one may doubt God’s mercy and Christ’s merit” — while no one may presume on it either, since looking at ourselves is the wrong place to look (§36).

Two open books side by side on a worn wooden table in a shaft of warm light, with a gold chalice softly out of focus behind them.

“Together we confess: By grace alone, in faith in Christ's saving work and not because of any merit on our part, we are accepted by God and receive the Holy Spirit.”

Joint Declaration on Justification, §15

What Actually Changed

The Condemnations No Longer Apply

The sixteenth century did not merely disagree. Trent anathematised positions, and the Lutheran confessions condemned the Roman teaching. Those condemnations were never repealed. What changed is the judgement about whom they hit.

Two pairs of hands, one older and one younger, clasped in agreement over an open Bible on a worn wooden table in a shaft of warm light.
✦ Two communions, one confession — on this doctrine, at least, and formally.

“The teaching of the Lutheran churches presented in this Declaration does not fall under the condemnations from the Council of Trent. The condemnations in the Lutheran Confessions do not apply to the teaching of the Roman Catholic Church presented in this Declaration.”

Joint Declaration, §41

“Nothing is thereby taken away from the seriousness of the condemnations … They remain for us “salutary warnings” to which we must attend in our teaching and practice.”

Joint Declaration, §42

Read those two paragraphs together. The anathemas still stand as warnings, and they no longer divide these two churches — because each has recognised that the other is not actually teaching what was condemned. Both churches have come “to new insights” rather than to amnesia (§7).

What it does not mean

It is not full communion

The Declaration resolves the doctrine of justification. It does not resolve the papacy, the sacramental economy, the ordination of ministers, the Marian dogmas, or the canon of the Mass. Those are named in §43 as still needing clarification, and they are still real divisions.

It does not apply to every Protestant body

The signatories were the Lutheran World Federation and the Catholic Church. Other Lutheran churches — notably the Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod — declined it, judging that it conceded too much or said too little. It is a settlement with the LWF, and its later associations with Methodist, Anglican and Reformed communions, not with “Protestantism” as a whole.

It does not say the two teachings are identical

§40 speaks of a “consensus in basic truths”, with differing language and emphasis that are “open to one another” — not of an identity of formulations. The 1999 Official Common Statement and its Annex, published with the Declaration, set out exactly how the Catholic Church reads the condemnation clause.

It does not make the differences disappear

The Declaration is a floor, not a ceiling. It establishes that the thing that once split Europe is no longer a valid reason for a split. Everything else must now be argued on the assumption that we are not separated on this — which is precisely what makes the remaining arguments so much harder to walk away from.

What Remains Open

The Paragraph the Churches Wrote About Themselves

The Declaration is not triumphalist. It ends by naming, in its own text, what it has not solved — and it calls the consensus “a solid basis” for solving it.

“There are still questions of varying importance which need further clarification. These include, among other topics, the relationship between the Word of God and church doctrine, as well as ecclesiology, ecclesial authority, church unity, ministry, the sacraments, and the relation between justification and social ethics.”Joint Declaration, §43
A wide golden shaft of sunlight from a tall Gothic window falling across an empty worn stone floor, dust motes suspended in the beam.
✦ Grace is not a thing we possess. It is light falling where it wills — and the rest of the argument is about where it is given.

Word of God and church doctrine

The rule of faith: Scripture read through the Church, and what a Church's doctrine may bind.

Ecclesiology and authority

Whether Christ gave a visible, universal pastoral office with the keys — the papacy question, still unanswered.

Church unity and ministry

One Church or many churches; ordination, apostolic succession, and who may preside at the altar.

The sacraments

Seven or two; what a sacrament does; the real presence and the sacrifice of the Mass.

Justification and social ethics

Whether grace compels the Church to speak on politics, economics and the family — and how.

How It Happened

From Anathemas to a Signed Agreement

1517–1547

The dispute and the condemnations

The Reformation breaks over indulgences and justification. The Lutheran confessions anathematise the Roman position; the Council of Trent (Decree on Justification, Session VI, 1547) anathematises the Reformed one. Both remain on the books.

1972–1986

Dialogue does the groundwork

The Lutheran–Catholic joint commission produces “The Gospel and the Church” (1972) and “Church and Justification” (1994); the US dialogue publishes “Justification by Faith” (1983); German theologians publish “The Condemnations of the Reformation Era — Do They Still Divide?” (1986). The Declaration stands on these.

31 Oct 1999

Signed at Augsburg

Cardinal Edward Cassidy and Bishop Christian Krause sign the Joint Declaration in Augsburg — the city of the 1530 Augsburg Confession. The Official Common Statement and its Annex are issued the same day.

2006

The Methodists associate

The World Methodist Council formally associates itself with the Declaration, and adds its own affirmation of the doctrine it contains.

2016

The Anglicans associate

The Anglican Consultative Council adopts resolution 16.17, associating the Anglican Communion with the Declaration and its affirmations.

2017

The Reformed associate

The World Communion of Reformed Churches formally associates with the Declaration — the tradition of Calvin and the Reformed confessions, joining the settlement its own theologians had argued for.

2019

Five communions affirm together

A consultation at Notre Dame publishes a joint statement, and the Lutheran World Federation and the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity issue a 20th-anniversary edition gathering the Catholic, Lutheran, Methodist, Anglican and Reformed statements in one volume.

If the hinge has been fixed, what is left to argue about?

Everything else — and that is the point. A Catholic can now say to a Lutheran: we are not divided on how a sinner is made right with God. So the questions that remain are not about whether grace is free, but about where grace is given, who may absolve, what happens at the altar, and who keeps the Church in the truth. Those are worth arguing about precisely because the foundation is no longer in dispute.

Read the Catholic case on justification
Short Study Guide

Reading the Declaration Together

Eight questions for a group or for private reflection. Read the section named beside each question first — the answers are in the text, not in the air. Allow ninety minutes for a group, or take one question a day for eight days.

Open the declaration itself, §1–§44, alongside this page. Read a paragraph aloud, then let the questions do the work. Nobody needs to defend a tradition; the point is to see what both churches now say together, and to name honestly what they do not.

01

Both churches now confess that we are justified by grace alone, in faith in Christ, and not because of any merit of our own. What did you assume the other side believed before you read this, and where did that assumption come from?

Read §15 and §16

02

The declaration says Catholics and Lutherans can each affirm that the justified are changed inwardly, and each deny that this change is a human achievement. Which half of that sentence is harder for you to say with a whole heart?

Read §19–§21

03

Lutherans insist that justification remains the work of God from beginning to end, and Catholics insist that grace is real enough to make us new. Where do these two insistences actually meet, and where do they still lean apart?

Read §25–§26

04

On faith and works: what is the difference between a work done to earn salvation and a work done because grace is at work in us? Give an example from your own week of each kind.

Read §27–§33

05

In 1999 the Catholic Church did not withdraw a single condemnation from the Council of Trent; it affirmed that those condemnations do not apply to the Lutheran teaching as now presented. Why does that distinction matter for the way you speak about the Reformation?

Read §4 and §13

06

The declaration deliberately uses a 'differentiated consensus', which John Paul II described as agreement in the one truth with differing formulations. Is that a real agreement or a diplomatic one — and what would a Catholic concede if it were only diplomatic?

Read §18, §43 and this page's opening section

07

The declaration says the remaining differences are no longer church-dividing, and it also says they must be taken seriously. Rank the four open questions on this page (the papacy, the Eucharistic sacrifice, the saints, and justification's final scope) by how much they still matter to you. What shapes that ranking?

Read §18 and §42–§44

08

Our Lord prayed for one visible unity so that the world might believe. Name one concrete thing you could do in the next six months that moves toward that prayer — not a feeling, but an act: a conversation, a book, a prayer, a visit, an apology.

Read John 17:21 · §44

Begin and end the session with the same prayer: 'Lord Jesus, you prayed that we might be one. Make us honest about what still divides us, grateful for what you have already restored, and willing to be made one in your own way and your own time.'

Share this page

Share this page with anyone who needs to hear it.