Fairness requires stating the other side properly. The classic Protestant answer is not stupid and it is not dishonest: Scripture alone is the rule of faith, the Spirit teaches each believer as he reads, and the unity of the Church is spiritual rather than juridical. That answer has produced saints, martyrs, missionaries and revivals. It deserves to be weighed, not dismissed.
But it has to be weighed against three questions, and it must answer all three, not one.
Question 1
Which account explains the promises?
Matthew 16:18, Luke 22:32 and John 21:15–17 are not scattered devotional verses; they are a coherent commissioning. An account of the Church has to do something with them other than soften them.
Question 2
Which account explains Acts 15?
Real dispute, real assembly, real judgment, real letter — and churches strengthened by receiving a decision. If the pattern was good enough for the apostles, it is not an act of unbelief to think Christ meant it to continue.
Question 3
Which account explains the Bible you hold?
The twenty-seven books were recognised, listed and defended by a Church before any of us could read them. Whatever you believe about authority, you are already the beneficiary of a decision.
None of this asks you to admire an institution. It asks you to consider that Christ, knowing what His Church would face — the sifting of Satan, the wolves, the centuries, the empires, the scandals — did not leave her with a text and a good intention. He left her with a man, a key, and a prayer that his faith would not fail.
You may still conclude that the office was a later growth. But you should reach that conclusion having read Clement's letter to Corinth, Irenaeus on Rome, the acts of Chalcedon, and the definition of 1870 for yourself — and having asked what, in the absence of such an office, is supposed to keep the promise of Matthew 16:18 from becoming a pious hope.
“I have prayed for you that your faith may not fail; and when you have turned again, strengthen your brethren.” He said that to one man, about the rest of us.